Supercell has dropped a bomb on the mobile gaming market. Their new game, Clash Royale, soft launched just as 2016 got started. They have soft launched in only 8 countries, but this game is already a sure success. Supercell has already committed the game to a global launch in March.
Supercell has made a lot of smart choices with this game. They have a fun, competitive, forward-thinking game that exemplifies what modern free to play design should feel like. Previously I’ve talked about just how difficult Multiplayer on Mobile is to get right, yet here Supercell threw out the rulebook. They’ve now proven that Synchronous multiplayer can work on mobile. Many have even gone as far to say this is the first successful MOBA on Mobile.
Whatever you want to call this game, it will be a success, and it did so while breaking many of the rules.
But enough praise for the game, today I’d like to talk about my favourite subject when it comes to mobile game design: sessions. Specifically, where I think Clash Royale succeeded in creating session design that pulls players back each day.
They did so with 2 clever systems:
- Free Chest Systems
- Chest Slot System
Overview of the Game
Clash Royale is a card-based real-time strategy game. The best way to explain it is to watch:
Player use cards to spawn various units to attack opposing player’s towers. The goal is to destroy their towers before they destroy yours. The strategy is in choosing when and where to place your cards: to counter your opponent’s units, and to ultimately press the opponent enough to destroy their central tower.
Overall it is a hectic strategic game that lasts only a few minutes. It feels like a real-time hearthstone match mixed up with the clash of clans gameplay.
- Winning a battle will reward you with chests (in various ways)
- These chests give you random rewards: gems, coins, and random cards
- Cards can be upgraded with enough duplicates of the same card, and enough coins
- To win, you need a variety of Levelled up cards
- Players want a collection of competitive cards
- To win as many matches as possible
- To get as many crowns and trophies as possible
- To reach highest Arenas
- To reach the top of the leaderboard (With your clan or by yourself)
The loop is focused on collecting and gathering cards. Not unlike Hearthstone. The big modification though is the ability to upgrade these cards.
To upgrade a card, you need to collect duplicates as well as coins. The real key comes in the rarity of the cards. Some cards are inherently better than others (ex. the Giant), and since they are RARE or EPIC, they drop a lot less than others. So not only do you want to collect these rare cards, you also need to collect a lot of them to fully upgrade the card.
This strong desire to collect and upgrade your cards is what drives all systems in the game. Each session is about attempting to get as many chests (and thus cards) as possible. To collect cards the fastest, the player has to play by the rules that Supercell desires to drive retention and monetization.
#1: The Free Chests System
To analyze Clash Royale’s sessions, let’s start with the most obvious system: how Clash Royale starts and ends its sessions.
For any game, good session design is marked by two things:
- You’re rewarded each time you come back to the game
- The game quickly gives you a short-term goal, that can be accomplished within that session, or at least within a few sessions
This is usually accomplished in most games by a few things:
A Rewarding Start:
Good sessions always start off with a instantly rewarding mechanic. Most games aim to have a collection of resources each time you return or a Daily Reward System. This gives the player a good feeling instantly after starting up the game.
Short Term Goal:
But having an instantly gratifying mechanic isn’t enough. The player must quickly form a goal which will drive the player further into the game. They need a goal which asks them to engage in the core gameplay.
This dynamic is usually created by a Daily Mission system or wanting to use up all Energy.
Clash Royale creates these 2 dynamics with 2 systems: A free chest every 4 hours, and a crown chest after collecting 10 crowns.
The free chest system marks the beginning of your session: you come in, open up your free chests. It feels rewarding just to come back.
Secondly, the crown chest. To open you must collect 10 crowns from opponents. This gives me a nice short term goal. Even if I am far away from ranking up, I want to collect 10 crowns so I get the crown chest. Realistically this goal can be accomplished in 1 session, or at least within a day.
This is perfect for driving a strong session length. A clear goal as soon as they’ve opened up the app. Something that the player feels good for accomplishing.
This chest can be opened once per 24 hours, which gives a strong daily goal for players. Players wanting to get the maximum number of chests come back each day and play enough matches to collect 10 crowns.
These 2 chests, which take up a small portion of the UI, incentivize strong sessions per day and strong session length.
#2: The Chest Slots System
Secondly lets look at the Chest Slot system.
Each time you play a round, if you win (score more crowns than the opponent), you will receive a chest. This chest is randomly chosen from Silver, Gold or Magical. Each chest takes time to open: 3h, 8h or 12h. You can only open 1 chest at a time, and to restrict things further, you only have 4 slots to store chests.
No other game on mobile has used this pattern for pacing players. This is the first I have ever seen someone attempt something like this. Instead of pacing the players through energy or construction timers, they went with a system that limits the rewards players get. Players can play as often as they like, but in order to progress and upgrade their deck, they need to pace themselves.
This system can only work if they know that :
#1: players won’t grow tired of playing their game… no matter how much they play
#2: their matchmaking and card upgrade system can prevent players from progressing into the higher leagues too fast
#1 is no easy feat, but I believe they accomplished it. Clash Royale is a game, like Hearthstone, that has a shifting meta, no clear answers. Every battle feels different, especially because its synchronous multiplayer.
#2 is based on the big change they made over a pure Trading Card Game system. Because you can upgrade each card, eventually the player will be confronted with decks that are stacked against them. No amount of skill will be able to defeat a deck with higher level units. Because of this, players will eventually need to play the chest opening game. There’s no avoiding it.
Matchmaking aside, what about the overall feeling of the sessions?
This system fulfills the goals of Flexible Sessions. Rather than blocking the player from playing the game, they ask the players to be smart about how they spend their time.
But what about having to come back every 3 hours to clear out a single chest? Why not allow for chests to be opened up automatically? Opened up in queue?
My guess is that Supercell knows the pain that the chest slots creates, and this is intentional for retention and monetization purposes. Players have to organize themselves to hit all their timers. This uncertainty of hitting their Chest Timers drives players to come back, and pay to speed up the timers when they know they won’t be able to return optimally. I know for myself this chest slot system has converted me into paying to skip timers.
But regardless if you’re chest slots are full, the player can continue to play, which really is what drives the flexible sessions. Even if you’ve filled up your chest slots there is a lot of productive things you can do in the game:
- You can continue to play and push as far up the leaderboard as you can go with your current cards
- You can continue to collect crowns for the Crown Chest
- You can donate cards and request cards from clan mates
- You can chat and read messages from other clan mates
- You can watch other battles from around Clash Royale (and be teased of late game content or tempted to speed up progression…)
So although the Chest system is restrictive, its not nearly as restrictive as a straight up energy system. And having this “soft” restriction allows highly engaged players to opt-in to leaving the game when they feel smart about it.
Supercell have a big success on their hands with Clash Royale.
They crafted strong sessions with 2 systems:
- A Free Chest system that gives rewards just for arriving and setting a strong session goal
- A Chest Slot system that effectively paces players without energy
This base of strong session design is driving strong retention and monetization. I don’t expect Supercell to change much as this game moves towards global launch. I expect that they are mostly focusing on making their end game deeper and more competitive. This will drive the game even further up the Top Grossing charts, and drive even stronger long term retention. This game will be on the charts for a long time to come.
Overall Supercell clearly have opened up new doors with their designs. It shows that synchronous multiplayer can work on mobile, and energy is not needed to pace players properly. Lets see whether this ushers in a new “Clash of Royale Clones” or developers can apply these design lessons to new games on mobile.
9 thoughts on “Deconstructing Clash Royale”
Hey it’s been a while but thanks for posting another great article! I haven’t gotten to play this yet but it definitely sounds addicting. If the game causes a shakeup, I hope it ushers in more games without energy systems and gives more developers the confidence to satisfy this:
“players won’t grow tired of playing their game… no matter how much they play”
One thing I am quite curious to see how they handle is long-term engagement and progression. You don’t mention it in the article, but cards are tied to arenas, so that players can’t find high-end cards until they have unlocked the high-level arenas.
This gives a good sense of progression in the early game, but also means that bad players (like me) can’t even hope to get the best cards, since I am unable to progress beyond arena 4. Going forward it will be interesting to see how Supercell adds new cards to the mix and what the requirements will be to unlock them. If it is just arena-based then low skill players won’t feel capable of even unlocking the new content.
This also has a weird effect on spending behavior, since players might (falsely?) think that the cards from the high-level arenas are better, and thus you should buy chests from the store until you are at max arena level…
As far as I’ve seen, with enough dedication, you’ll eventually get to higher arenas through sheer upgrades of your cards. You’ll collect enough of Arena 4 cards to upgrade past your competition in that arena, and eventually will go to Arena 5. It’s true that Arena 4 is the first bump on the road, and it’s been so far the longest Arena to pass for me. I think it’s made to drive you to invest in order to go to further Arenas (mostly because the leveling for cards start to be more expensive and harder to obtain without paying). This is their second strong conversion point. First the timers of the Chests, then the slowing down of progression through Arenas.
Regarding your comment on higher Arenas being not as interesting as they make it sound (at least that’s what I understand from your last sentence :), it’s not exactly true.
The higher the Arena, the more gold and cards per chest you get, and thus the faster you can level up your existing cards, on top of getting new ones that are different (maybe better), and more specialized, making the meta game more changing at higher Arenas.
So it’s interesting to get to higher Arenas for progression, regardless of whether the new cards are better or not.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, sorry. That was a misunderstanding: What I meant was that players feel disincentivized to buy chests from the shop (not unlocks from the earned chests), as long as they feel like they progress within a reasonable time frame, simply because buying chests from the shop becomes progressively better.
I also definitely feel that Arena 4 is the first spike and from talking to other players it seems like this is where most people first feel it.
Was the same for me, slows down at Arena 4, a little bit grindy at this point. Great game overall though.